Ep 32 Alwin Tan
===
[00:00:00]
Sharee Johnson: This conversation with Dr. Alwin Tan is a unique conversation to the extent that we spend quite a lot of time talking about the governance of healthcare and the challenges for clinicians using their voice and, putting their hand up to be involved in governance and leadership kind of issues.
Sharee Johnson: As you'll hear, Alwin is interested in how we have more conversations that might be uncomfortable or even inconvenient. I really like this addition of [00:01:00] inconvenient. Some of the conversations that we're having might not be that uncomfortable. We might actually have a lot of agreement about the problems and the solutions, but it might feel a bit inconvenient, like when is the right time?
Sharee Johnson: When can we find the funding? If we go up road A, we're gonna have to put off going up road B, which might also be important. So this idea of having conversations that are uncomfortable and inconvenient in health is very interesting to me. I, I'm gonna be thinking about that a lot after talking with Alwin I'm very interested to hear any feedback from you as well. Alwin's thinking a lot about how do we have think tank, robust kind of conversations with people who are outside of health as well as people who are inside of health, and how do we really draw out or expand what we can see, what might be possible?
Sharee Johnson: When, when I asked Alwin about AI, he, uh, made an interesting reflection, I think, about who is gonna have the stop button in certain circumstances and who will have [00:02:00] the go button. So we had an interesting conversation about who has responsibility for what in the world of AI and this challenge that often happens for doctors and, and perhaps for other health professionals around responsibility, that as the clinician, as the frontline clinician who's closest to the patient, you're often bearing all of the responsibility.
Sharee Johnson: But what about the people who wrote the policies or designed the AI product that you're using? How do we want to shift or understand or question this responsibility? Who has responsibility for what?
Sharee Johnson: One of the things Alwin said right near the end of the conversation is that it really makes his soul burn. What a powerful expression. When, people fall back on saying, "We followed the procedure."
Sharee Johnson: Now we were talking specifically about, uh, governance and, and lawyers. But I think we've probably all had this experience of saying or [00:03:00] wanting to say, "Well, we followed the procedure." But where does that really leave us, and does that have integrity? I think there are lots of big questions in this conversation with Dr. Alwin Tan. I hope that it adds to your reflections and leads to lots more interesting conversations about governance of health, leadership in health, integrity, things like AI and, future education that we might need in healthcare.
Sharee Johnson: Dr. Alwin Tan is a specialist surgeon, a healthcare governance leader, innovator, founder of the Institute of Systems Integrity, and chief executive of- officer and chief medical officer of MyVitals Vault, a healthcare technology venture focused on patient-controlled health information and better care coordination.
Sharee Johnson: Alwin is a graduate of the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Melbourne and a fellow of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons. He has spent more than two decades [00:04:00] caring for patients while advocating for clinical safety, professional wellbeing, and better healthcare systems.
Sharee Johnson: Dr. Tan's journey beyond surgery has included an executive MBA at the Melbourne Business School, graduation from the Australian Institute of Company Directors, studies in artificial intelligence in healthcare at Harvard Medical School, and sustainable business at the University of Oxford. He is also a triple scholar of the Bastas Academy of Health Leadership, a graduate of the Australian Clinical Entrepreneurs Program, and has engaged with Australia's digital health innovation ecosystem through ANDHealth.
Sharee Johnson: An important part of his personal journey has been his long-standing relationship with Wurundjeri elder Murrundindi, who welcomed him into his family and gave him the name Mamuk. This relationship has profoundly shaped Alwin's understanding of culture, belonging, inclusion, and the importance of [00:05:00] listening before leading.
Sharee Johnson: In 2027, Dr. Tan will commence a Master of Health and Medical Law at Melbourne Law School, University of Melbourne, further exploring the intersection of healthcare, ethics, governance, accountability, and justice.
Sharee Johnson: Through the Institute of Systems Integrity, he advocates for safer healthcare, ethical leadership, and organizations that not only have the courage to recognize when things go wrong, but also the integrity and the capacity to put them right.
Sharee Johnson: His evolving journey reflects a simple belief, caring for individual patients is important, but improving the systems that care for thousands may be one of the greatest contributions a clinician can make.
Sharee Johnson: so Alwin, it's just amazing to have some time with you today. Thank you for, joining me on Recalibrating with Sharee Johnson.
Dr Alwin Tan: I'm honored to be a guest on your list, and I am, um, very chuffed because this is a good moment to reflect [00:06:00] where I am, where I've been, and where I'm going to. So thank you for inviting me.
Sharee Johnson: Well, let's dig straight in. How did you come to choose medicine as your career?
Dr Alwin Tan: Ah. I came from a families of, uh, international lawyers and, and human rights, um, champions and social justice, um, leaders.
Dr Alwin Tan: I chose medicine because I think at the age of 10, if I remember that correctly, my mom had a massive miscarriage. She bled in front of me, collapsed. Mm. And I had to call the ambulance because Dad was away. And next thing you know, she went to the hospital and did not ... And we didn't hear for two days, 'cause I was at home with my sister.
Dr Alwin Tan: And finally we got a phone call from the doctor saying, "Your mom is okay. We've saved her."
Sharee Johnson: Wow.
Dr Alwin Tan: That important phone call was important to me because, one, I wanna be one of those people that save life. And two, I [00:07:00] wanna be one of those people that delivered good informations and happy information.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: I think the second thing that really came to mind was when my father introduced us to a family friend we, which we call Uncle, because of cultural background.
Dr Alwin Tan: And at the age of 12, I was invited to spend my holidays with him scrubbed up operating.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that got me hooked for life. Imagine a 12-year-old boy standing on a little stand, scrubbed up with mask, holding, looking at how tissues get handled, and the culture in theater. And that was my destiny.
Sharee Johnson: What an incredible experience for a 12-year-old.
Sharee Johnson: I can't imagine that happening these days.
Dr Alwin Tan: No. You, you, you'll need, you'll need the, uh, you know, the Facebook, Instagram and a computer tablet.
Sharee Johnson: And many pieces- there's a paper still signed to get a 12-year-old into the theater
Dr Alwin Tan: Absolutely.
Sharee Johnson: And has [00:08:00] it, has it met your 12-year-old expectations?
Sharee Johnson: Have you had the experiences that you hoped you would as a doctor?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think as a doctor, I set out to help the person in front of me. I set out to be the best I could be. I set out to look after the ecosystem around it and build it around people, staff, patients. And I think it has been a beautiful j- journey.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know, at 20 years as a surgeon, been a while since I graduated from Melbourne Uni as a, as a doctor, and then a fellowship in surgery. It has been beautiful, rewarding, learning. Uh, but, but the best teachers has been every patient of mine.
Speaker 2: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Every one of them would still give me hugs every day and says, "Thank you."
Dr Alwin Tan: You know, they have been my best teachers, good and bad times.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: They have been knowledge that I will carry with me for the rest of my life.
Sharee Johnson: Mm, mm. And [00:09:00] I, I should... It's remiss of me not to just acknowledge your mum and that experience that she had. And as a child, that must have been frightening to wonder, you know, where your mum had gone and when she was coming back, if she was coming back.
Dr Alwin Tan: It, it is a very stressful thing and, and therefore I think, you know, I, I made it a deal to call families these days af- after operating to tell them that, "Hey, you know, they're doing well." To talk to them and to invite families to come in for discussions, making an open, transparent thing. And there will be certain family members that says, "Can you call me immediately after the surgery?"
Dr Alwin Tan: And you know that's my little boy that I was in once.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I understand that I'm now on the other side of the story.
Sharee Johnson: Mm. So important, isn't it, to remember these things from our earlier life. Because I've, read your bio and everybody's heard the many, many things that you're involved in, Alwin, can you tell us a little bit about how you manage this portfolio career?
Sharee Johnson: You've got lots of things going on in lots of different places. How, how do you manage all [00:10:00] those parts and, some things like how do you know when you need to say, "I can't put anything else on the plate," or how, how do you manage that?
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I, I think, um, in my first 20 years I only had one speed.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm. Which is to go as hard as you can, the best as you can, and provide the best care you can. And in the last five years or so, my journey has, ha- has changed. I've changed from being a doctor trying to look after the patient in front of me, but now trying to question and change the system behind me-
Sharee Johnson: Mm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: so that we could drive this ecosystem through.
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I realized that just one person working hard to help a particular patient or a team against patient is not enough. We have to start questioning the system that allows us to do well- And also the system that allows us to do badly- Mm ... and the system that does badly, they get to get away with things. And suddenly I think [00:11:00] my maturity has come about to stand backwards.
Dr Alwin Tan: And as I stand backwards, I realize that some of my clinical work has to go. Mm. And, and so at a stage in my life, I'm giving more complicated, more, um, sort of high-risk operation to younger and more junior doctors coming through and to mentor them and to give them chances to do things.
Dr Alwin Tan: Because my chance now is about governance, it's about integrity, and also about innovation.
Dr Alwin Tan: And so I scale down my practice, I reduce my on-call, and at the same time I gear up in a lot more things coming through, and it's exciting. Mm. It is very, very exciting because when I was doing medicine, I knew the world this much. And when I chose to do, to go to Melbourne Business School and do my MBA, I realized that there's a world out there-
Sharee Johnson: Mm
Dr Alwin Tan: around it, and suddenly- The way I look at things changes, you know? It's about changing len- lenses, Sharee. Mm. It's [00:12:00] about standing back. It's about saying, "What will be my impact in the next 20 years?" Mm. And what, what, what system would I leave behind when, when it's my time to go?
Sharee Johnson: Ooh, so many things coming up for me.
Sharee Johnson: I'm, I'm noticing this plate metaphor, that you've gotta take some things off to put some things on, and I think, um, many of the doctors I talk to in coaching, uh, ... Maybe they don't forget that, but they have to go through that process of recognizing, okay, if I want to put these other things on or turn my attention elsewhere, something has to give or go.
Sharee Johnson: Uh, so that's one thing. And then also this thing about the wood for the trees metaphor, that when you're in medicine, such a strong culture with very strong cultural norms that, um, it is easy to forget. You know, the fish doesn't know the water they swim in. All these metaphors happening for
Dr Alwin Tan: me. Abso- absolutely.
Dr Alwin Tan: Ab- Yeah. Great I absolutely agree, Sharee. Absolutely agree.
Sharee Johnson: And getting, and getting out to somewhere like the M- the Melbourne Business School, what you're not only with healthcare professionals. You all have a common interest in governance and, and business and learning, [00:13:00] but from lots of different industries.
Sharee Johnson: Can you share a little bit about that experience?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think it was an amazing experience. Uh, when I, when I chose to, uh, to, to interview for it, I was one of the few doctors who, who got in. And my concern was, um, you know, will I be able to contribute? Mm. And, and so I was asked this question in my interview saying, "You know, a lot of people are bringing lots of skills in, but what will you, you bring in?"
Dr Alwin Tan: And I, and I, and I said that, you know, "I'm gonna bring humanity in because those of you who sat here across the table, when you have cancer, you will come to me, and I will show you what humanity means." And, and I think that was just the thing that got me across in the interview. But what was important for me was to realize that across culture, across different industries, and ac- across different platforms, everyone has similar problems.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: We all have a systemic problem [00:14:00] where we're trying to solve little problems at the same time, but trying to influence change in the systemic sphere. I was so happy to learn everything from all my colleagues, who came in with all the different experience from banking to mining, to trains, to psychology, to operations, to things that I've never heard of.
Dr Alwin Tan: Uh, and I wrote a number of new words that I've learned. It was about, like, 4,000 new words, and I was so excited. Every day I run into Melbourne Business School saying, "I want to learn something else today." And that actually changed me. That changed me in the way of approaching a systemic approach to problem.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that allows me, in the end, because I loved this discussion, which then helped me to build the Institute for Systems Integrity, to invite people across platform to talk about their problems, to offer solutions to openly discuss things that people find hard to discuss or uncomfortable [00:15:00] to discuss or even inconvenient to discuss.
Dr Alwin Tan: And part of the discussion that was so open in Melbourne Business School that I still miss today is people just talk and says, "Well, I've got a problem in my industry. Let me share it with you." Mm. And then I really learned from that. And I think that was one of my growing spurt years, that I never feel- thought that I would still be growing at this age.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. Isn't that magnificent? I, I want to, um, restate something that I said at the end of your bio and just dig into the clinician bit a little bit more before we go to the what's behind the scenes, because I think that's where we'll spend most of our conversation. Just to remind our listeners you've heard this already once today, Alwin says, "His evolving journey reflects a simple belief that caring for individual patients is important, but improving the systems that care for thousands may be one of the greatest contributions a clinician can make."
Sharee Johnson: I really want to zero in on the clinician word. Mm. I think, um, doctors talk a lot about the system and the executives and the [00:16:00] administration and, you know, this separation. They don't necessarily see them- they see themselves as a clinician. That's the identity or, in your case, the surgeon or whatever their specialty is.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. Is it a big identity shift to move from thinking about clinician to thinking about, um, uh, systems analysis or governance or these other things that you're focusing on now?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think, Sharee, I think you, you, you pointed out a very big point. You know, as doctors, we're always trained to obey. We're always trained to comply.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm-hmm. We're always trained to do what's right, and for a while, we believe that the system is correct- Mm-hmm ... the system will protect us, and the system will look after everyone. Mm-hmm. But when you start to step back, you realize that the, the, the system has its faults, has its problem, and some of the faults continues today, and some of the faults still affects patient, staff members, and everyone.[00:17:00]
Dr Alwin Tan: And unless clinician starts to step back and said, "Hey, I'm good at doing what I do, but I need to have a say. I need to be involved in the systemic management policy making and the governance," we will always run into that same problem. Mm-hmm. That we'll have a new management, new executive, new policies that will affect us, and we would not have a say in saying something.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and I think it is a time of change. It is a time I hope that more and more clinician will see that we need to speak up. Mm-hmm. And that's the hard part, Sharee, because the old culture is if you speak up, it becomes a career suicide.
Sharee Johnson: I think that's true for lots of people. Lots of people come to coaching saying, "You know, I've been trying to speak up.
Sharee Johnson: I've been on this committee or that committee. I've written this letter. I can show you my five years of email trail. It gets no response." You know, these kinds of things that, many of the people who reach those points where they bring these [00:18:00] things to coaching are saying, "I give up," or, "I don't want to give up, but I don't know what else to do."
Sharee Johnson: Uh, what's your encouragement for people at those junctures?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think we need to find like people, number one. We need to find like people to talk to because we are not alone in this problem.
Sharee Johnson: I couldn't endorse- I couldn't endorse that more. I think the collective voice is just so important. Sorry, carry on.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and, and I think it is so important to have a collective platform where people could actually s- speak and discuss and, and, and do things. And, and part of what I try to do is open that platform up so people can then talk about things, you know? I, I, I give you an, an, an example of happening in some hospital, no names mentioned, around locally.
Dr Alwin Tan: The standard average for nursing staff is one nurse to four patient. In any public hospital, you can't break that rule unless you have exceptional circumstances. In private hospitals, we're trying to drive the KPI up because [00:19:00] driven by incentives to executive. They are now driving one nurse to five to six to seven to eight to nine to 10 patients.
Dr Alwin Tan: And unfortunately Things are going to go wrong because you cannot run capacity at 200% and said you're absolutely correct. Mm. But when things goes wrong, the system starts to blame them. Mm. And, and these nurses comes to me because they get reported to AHPRA for missing something, for missing something that leads to bad outcomes.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm. And all these nurses as they're crying in my room and, and discussing what can they do, feeling very, very helpless. We have to think that, well, if there is a body that, you know, checks our compliance, checks our integrity, like AHPRA for you and I, Sharee.
Sharee Johnson: Yes.
Dr Alwin Tan: But where is the body for the executive?
Speaker 2: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: In, in healthcare, [00:20:00] the, the following person can say, "Yes, I did missed this." But what about the executive who drove me to see so many patients and I didn't have a choice to say no? Mm. A- a- and I think that's a big questions that as a community, as a governance society, as a ministry, as a country, that we, we, i- it's time to come and have a, that conversation.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know, if you work in the banking industry, there's ASX, there's APRA. If you work in a casino like the Crown Casino, there are bodies that looks after you. But in healthcare for some reason, there is a blind spot-
Dr Alwin Tan: That Fair Work, Safe Work Australia, Victoria, someone has missed this. Mm. And I think it's time for all of us to have that conversation. Accountability has to point in both direction and not keep pointing downwards. And I, I think that's one of the biggest thing that we need to actually change. Mm. And yeah.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. You're reminding me [00:21:00] again for the listeners to give some meat to this, something to hang onto.
Sharee Johnson: I interviewed Duncan Brown, earlier on this year in the podcast, and Duncan's son died of sepsis very awfully as a young man, 20 year old, in an emergency department. There was all sorts of rev- reviews and inquiries and so on. Um, and what it came down to essentially was the junior doctor who hadn't had the training and didn't have the support.
Sharee Johnson: And Duncan has been very vocal in making sure that that junior doctor is not blamed for- and says, you know, if the emergency department was dealing with 200% or whatever of the, what it's actually capable of dealing with, then that's a bigger systemic problem that's not about that one junior doctor.
Sharee Johnson: The, the other thing that you're having me think about is, uh, some early meetings I went to a couple of years ago, uh, about the AI scribes, and the doctors were saying to their insurance companies, "Why do I have to have all the responsibility for all the due dilige- diligence of understanding what each scribe is doing?
Sharee Johnson: Why isn't somebody, e.g. in this [00:22:00] example the insurance company providing some kind of policy or some kind of statement about how I do the due diligence or helping me do that?" And of course, RACGP and others have now written some policies to help individual doctors. But these, both of these examples are getting at what you're pointing to of the doctor appearing to hold all of the responsibility for trying to understand all the layers of how we got here.
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I think, I think you're absolutely correct, and I think we need to clarify that. I think AI is one of my pet subject, having done AI in Harvard and, uh, driving to innovation in AI. I fully appreciate what you're saying because when something goes wrong in AI and they can say, "Well, we accept 1%, 2% errors."
Dr Alwin Tan: But in medicine you're talking about one life, two lives or five life or 100 lives. That changes the whole policy, right? At the moment, the responsibility is the person [00:23:00] closest to the patient. So it's the user. It could be a junior doctor, it could be a nurse, it could be a surgeon. But I fully appreciate what you're saying that, well, what about the vendors who made the product?
Dr Alwin Tan: What about the people who are supposed to validate it? What about the- governance committee that approved this, the question then is who can push the stop button-
Sharee Johnson: Mm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: when you know there is a problem?
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And who can push the green button to start again?
Sharee Johnson: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I think as we try to drive AI through the industry, and no doubt it's changing every industry, medicine's gonna have that problem.
Dr Alwin Tan: Until we can say, "This AI's coming through, who's gonna push the stop button, and who can have the power to push the green button back on?" We are not gonna have a governance problem. We're only gonna throw the most junior person at the front desk under the bus every [00:24:00] time something happens, right? And if we get so dependent on this AI device or AI product, we may not be able to switch it off.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that wo- and that worries me because a- as I built a couple of, of the innovation that involves AI, that questions always come back to us in saying, how can we be responsible? How can we have trust, and how can we run this with good governance?
Sharee Johnson: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: I think that's a big question.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. So, so trust...
Sharee Johnson: So rights and responsibilities and trust. Let's talk about integrity, Alwin, 'cause that's a very big interest of yours, and I think that's where we are. We're sort of in that all of these things relate to integrity. So can you tell us about your, institute, Systems Integrity- Right ... and, uh, what you, what you hope to do there and, and the kinds of questions or processes you're...
Sharee Johnson: How, how are you applying it to, to these questions that we're, um- [00:25:00] pondering?
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, I, I, I have to say that it came out of a lot of frustration- of having many people with many questions who have ideas but no way to voice it. And it also came about from sitting around in Melbourne Business School with robust discussion with everyone, you know, where it was fair to say, "I don't agree with you.
Dr Alwin Tan: Uh, I think that's doesn't gel. Do you, do you realize this?" And I missed those discussion as I graduated from Melbourne Business School, and I wanted to continue that journey with lots of people who can discuss lots of things. So the only way was to start a platform which has no financial, incentives- where it becomes a, think tank where everyone from every institution can approach me and says, "Alwin, this is the problem in my industry. This is the way I look at it. This is the lens that I look at it, and could we [00:26:00] discuss this together? And here are some degree of solution." So it shouldn't be one that, that people sit down and just keep complaining.
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I like the fact that you have to offer some, uh, degree of solution- Mm ... or some degree of analysis. Mm. And that has only grown in li- the last 12 months. I mean, we are now in our 11th month. We'll have our anniversary in December this year, and it has grown a lot. It has brought up a lot of discussion. Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and we like to discuss things that are uncomfortable, that, uh, that everyone knows is out there, but no one wants to talk about it, that's a bit inconvenient. Mm. And it, and it, and, and it might put some people into some sort of, uh, thinking mode. Um, and so this was just, just a growing factors for me to grow, but for everyone else to grow, and hopefully the discussion would then spark lots of conversation and lots of thinking, and perhaps allow us to build a better system [00:27:00] down the track.
Sharee Johnson: So the Institute for Systems Integrity, can people join? How does it work?
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, so we have got a, presence in LinkedIn, and people write in. We've got an email address. And so I've had lots of people who have contributed- from around the world who I haven't met in person- Mm
Dr Alwin Tan: who has said, "Hey, I've got this idea. What do you think?"
Dr Alwin Tan: Do you think it, it's, it's worth talking about?" Mm. And that's how it actually starts.
Speaker 2: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and so to build a team that can talk about things-
Speaker 2: Mm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: uh, rather than to, you know, to encourage people to come up, because this is where you can speak up-
Sharee Johnson: Mm
Dr Alwin Tan: and n- and not have any, any issues at all.
Sharee Johnson: Can you tell us a little bit, Alwin, about what you think integrity means, a- and maybe particularly systems integrity?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think integrity is a very complex word. It's a word that I'll probably be coming to terms of [00:28:00] learning each time as I go along. At this stage, it means having a system that protects the people that it's supposed to serve, but at the same time, doing no harm to others.
Dr Alwin Tan: So you can have a company that said, "I want to make this much in profit and this much in KPI," but at the same time, it should not ignore its responsibility to the customers, to the workers, to the people that it impact upon while it tries to make money for the shareholders. Um, I think it's a very, very big issue.
Dr Alwin Tan: I think integrity means a lot of things, but for me, integrity means, in, in medicine and in healthcare, having a system that protects everyone who works in it, but driving at the right direction together to make it a better place for the patient , for the healthcare workers and for everyone involved in, in the system.
Dr Alwin Tan: And often, you know, when KPI and [00:29:00] incentives comes in, it is so easy for people to just realize that we'll just say what we say. We'll pretend that this is our culture, but behind closed door, we're only putting KPI ahead of everything else. Mm. And I think that's wrong, and I think, you know, it's almost like having a bully in, in the system.
Dr Alwin Tan: We should be able to call out the the bully in the, in, in the sandbox- Mm ... and say, "Hey, guys, girls, ladies, that is not the right thing to do." Mm. And so integrity for me is, is growing. I know I'm not answering your question, but it's a big, it's a big topic for me.
Sharee Johnson: Well, yeah, you kind of are. What I'm thinking about is have you got a, even a small example where you've seen integrity not operating or somebody challenging or maybe you've been able to challenge?
Sharee Johnson: Even some small example to give. What, what I'm looking for is to give our listeners some hope and also- Mm-hmm ... some ideas, some inspiration about how might they be able to call out the bully in the [00:30:00] sandbox. And I want to underline what we talked about before, this collective voice, that it's much easier to call somebody out as a group.
Dr Alwin Tan: I think one of the things that comes to term, and I get lots of email feedback from people who says, "I'd like to discuss this, but I do not want to be open about this. I don't want to put it in your LinkedIn, but I want to say I'm supporting you." Mm. So one of the biggest thing among, um, doctors and specialists working in private hospital is we're not treated the same as doctors, workers in a public hospital.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm. So as we sit in a private hospital, we realize that the cleaners have more rights under Fair Work Australia than we are. And we're not saying that the cleaners mean less than we are, but we're saying that everyone should be the same. So the old VMO rules and the, and the old Fair Works reg- legislation- Makes the VMO a contractor
Sharee Johnson: So I'll just tell when, for the listeners who don't know, visiting medical officers-
Dr Alwin Tan: Medical officers, yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: Which are with the [00:31:00] specialists, you and me ...
Sharee Johnson: means that they are es- you're essentially a contractor into the private hospital. Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. Yeah. Then, when you realize it, it's a very imbalanced power structure. You have an executive with such, so much power, and the healthcare front person in this much power.
Dr Alwin Tan: And so at any point in time, the executive could say, "I'm sorry, your service is no longer required. You have to go." Mm. That means losing your operating list, your consulting list, your presence, your identity, your ecosystem, and the people you work for, and the people you teach. That imbalance-
Sharee Johnson: And the people that you serve.
Sharee Johnson: If you have a list of people that you see in your- Oh ... private rooms who are your patients, and now
Dr Alwin Tan: you
Dr Alwin Tan: don't- Absolutely ...
Sharee Johnson: now you don't have a, an operating theater that's a big problem.
Dr Alwin Tan: Absolutely. And, and that imbalance has, I think, discouraged, sometimes retaliated, um, specialists and doctors from speaking up.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm. [00:32:00] And unless we address this imbalance, we, we are not gonna see a big change because from all the emails and feedbacks that I get, people are telling me what's happening, but they don't dare to speak up or they have been warned that if you continue to speak up, things will happen to you. And, and, and that becomes a really scary part because if the public knows that this is the case, I think there should be an outrage about it.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know? You, you know, if, if, if, if, if you are in a flying in industry and, and, and you are in the pilot industry, aviation industry, you're encouraged to speak up. In our industry, because of the cultural things change- You are not allowed to.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Or you, you can, but you will expect- Mm ... things to come your way.
Sharee Johnson: There, there's problems both directions, Alwin. I'm re- I'm remembering I was, uh, invited during the COVID years by a private hospital system to come and [00:33:00] make some videos for doctors about harassment and bullying and the way to behave and wellbeing, various things. Um, but the audience were the, the VMOs, the Visiting Medical Officers into this system.
Sharee Johnson: And, uh, I was saying to them, "Well, how will you actually make the doctors come to these sessions? What, what's the process? Where do these videos sit in the wider kind of work you're doing with your doctors? What, what's that mean? What's that look like?" Mm. And, um, essentially they The work didn't progress because of the questions I asked.
Sharee Johnson: They may have found a different way of doing it, but they didn't do it with me. Um- Yeah, right. And, uh, and they said, "Well, uh, the doctors probably won't come to these sessions. We don't know how we're gonna get, uh, them to access or be engaged because they will need to come on their own time, or, uh, they'll need to see less patients, or we can't really afford for them to see less patients."
Sharee Johnson: So they, they had this kind of bright idea that they needed to give some kind of education to the [00:34:00] VMOs, but there didn't seem to be a mechanism to actually bring the VMOs together. Or there, there didn't seem to be a shared ... , i don't think there'd been any consultation with the medical staff.
Sharee Johnson: It was coming from maybe HR or some other part of the system. It was kind of, it was very strange for me as a, as a external consultant that might be contracted in to do this work, to think about this sort of idea that, well, the doctors won't cooperate with this, and now you're saying, and also it goes the other way.
Sharee Johnson: So do you have any ideas about how this could be better?
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, um, one of my best and, um, who's, who's today I stand as my hero in management-
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: is, uh ... And as a young junior surgeon, I came back after overseas training, and I came back to a hospital, and the hospital was in financial trouble and it was in cultural trouble, and it has, um, lots of bad practices in [00:35:00] place.
Dr Alwin Tan: And a, and a new person came in, quite experienced, very senior, and, and he came down and he s- sat on the first day. And I can mention his name because Peter w- will, will be okay for me to talk about him because he's like my little mentor. I says, "Peter, it's going to be a big task. What are you gonna do?" He says, "Hey, since you have got a bit of time because your practice is not full yet, why don't you come with me?"
Dr Alwin Tan: And what Peter did was he went to different departments. So one day we had coffee with, with the gardeners and said, "Hey, guys, if you can do five things that can share for you-" Would you please tell me or write it down on a piece of yellow paper with no names and give it to me?
Speaker 2: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And then I'll think about what I can do to change it for you.
Dr Alwin Tan: So we went from department to department to department. Unusual for a CEO to do that. And I went with him. Every Friday I says, "Mate, I'm learning these things. I don't know what it's called." But [00:36:00] today, with the hindsight of MBA, that's walking the floor, right? And that sort of leaderships are so rare to come by.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I s- and I, one day we spent time with, with, with the orderlies, we spent time with the nurses, with... And so all these problems came about. And after six months he goes, "Alwin, we're ready to make a policy change." And those policy change were just questions, things that people wanted to do, and plus a bit of what he can do and what he can't do.
Dr Alwin Tan: And he said, "I know you guys requested for this, but at this point in time we can't afford to do this, but they'll be on the burner, and please keep asking again. I don't mind if you keep asking." Mm. And, and within 6 months, 12 months, he changed around the culture. He changed around the people, and he brought people behind his back.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I sat there in awe saying, "That is the type of leadership that I want to be."
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, little did I know that years down the track that I'll be trying to think about these [00:37:00] things. He also had this open policy door. On a Friday afternoon he keeps his door open. Anyone can pop in for a quick drink.
Speaker 2: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Vent whatever you want to, talk about what you want to.
Dr Alwin Tan: No retaliation And you can then walk out and he'll tell you- Mm ... doable, not doable, or I'm gonna think about it. A- and he's one of the, one of the leadership CEOs who didn't come from medicine, didn't come from health, but understood health and understood people. And more importantly, he listened, and he made it a safe environment.
Dr Alwin Tan: A- and, and I sat there while this robust discussion coming on, and someone said, "You know, that new policy of yours, it's a lot of BS." He goes, "Okay, tell me why." And then he goes, "Maybe it's a lot of BS. Maybe we have to reconsider this, you know?" And that's the sort of leadership we need. That's the sort of leadership we need.
Dr Alwin Tan: Not the ones that comes in with lots of titles, [00:38:00] lots of names, and says, "Okay, these are the parameters we set. You, you, you, you have to set these parameters because otherwise it will be carrot and, and stick pr- problem." And once you've set that parameter, "Oh no, we want some more." And, and, and no one actually think about the poor people, right?
Dr Alwin Tan: A- and, and people got listened. So we would sit down there and look through all the letters coming in together. A- and so I, I actually learned a lot from him.
Dr Alwin Tan: And to this day, I still think about Peter as one of my, you know, mentor, Yoda type of characters, and has taught me so much about governance, taught me so much about integrity, but more importantly, how it is important to be an authentic, transparent, and an inspiring leader.
Sharee Johnson: Mm. So you had an early interest in systems and you were, um, able to, uh, grab that opportunity, that exposure that you got in walking around with [00:39:00] Peter. It's also reminding me, this story, of how relational medicine is and how relational leadership is, that these are, these are people-based activities.
Sharee Johnson: And certainly I've said lots and lots of times, I mean, people are the system. People, people will make the system stop or start. Mm. Uh, can you tell us something about leadership, this story with Peter, but also your own leadership?
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm.
Sharee Johnson: For me, lead- leaders are bringing me somewhere.
Sharee Johnson: You know, I want to follow them I, I don't know if that's always what people mean when they say leadership
Dr Alwin Tan: I think leadership is a very, very fluid thing, and it keeps changing over time. Mm-hmm. Um, you know, when I first started, I have a clear idea of leadership. But these days I think about leadership as an adaptive capacity.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: That each s- situation warrants you to think, reflect, and think what's sort of best leadership to approach at that point in time. [00:40:00] Um, i- in some situation, it is best to sit back and let everybody talk about what they want to say first, because if you do say what you think, then not everyone is, is going to try to get on the bandwagon-
Sharee Johnson: Mm
Dr Alwin Tan: and then in the end to say what you want to say. Secondly about leadership is to allow people to speak up. In one of the boards that I sat in, and this is amazing board, um, two people in the board will be appointed as devil's advocate for the day. No matter what you believe in, your job is to pick holes at everything that comes through.
Dr Alwin Tan: You're gonna be that friction person that causes the problem. And so when you arrive that day, y- you are the friction person. You go, "Oh my God, uh, I'm gonna be a bad boy today," right? And because you're given the license to pick- And the two persons of two different background picking at every ideas, it actually make the discussion so robust.
Dr Alwin Tan: And people actually accept that because next time it could be one of them. [00:41:00] And those sort of leadership discussion where, the Chair of the Board can allow people to speak up, and rather than making everybody try to stamp all the ideas through, has actually make thinking so robust. And what we started out as a concept idea completely evolved by the time we finished the board meeting.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I think that's one of the things that I will definitely continue to adopt, adapt in, in the, in the whole thing. Because if you really make it a sporting thing to speak up, and it's not just speaking up. You know, speaking up is easy, but what happens to the person afterwards, after they speak up?
Dr Alwin Tan: That's the big thing about things, ? That's when culture comes in. Culture can be stuff that you talk about, you put on your walls and put the values, but it's what happens when it becomes uncomfortable, inconvenient. [00:42:00] What, how did you actually change? Yeah.
Sharee Johnson: Totally. Your story about Peter is really he was building trust all of the time.
Sharee Johnson: And, you know, trust comes from competence and relationship. And when you have those things and you have trust, then you can have a robust conversation. You, you know, you've got psychological safety. That- that's not what people describe in their jobs in medicine-
Dr Alwin Tan: No.
Sharee Johnson: No ... or more, more broadly in health. You know, they describe going into a meeting, people arrive late, people go early, people talk over the side, people sit in the back walls and don't contribute.
Sharee Johnson: Um, the bosses come in and say, "Right, we've got half an hour. We need to resolve this rostering issue or this whatever, whatever issue." Um, and, and people don't speak because they have messages of, "Oh, my opinion's not important. Nothing will be happen. I'll, I'll be hung out to dry. Uh, they've already made up their mind, so why bother?"
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm.
Sharee Johnson: What, what do we do about the time factor? 'Cause that's a big part of it, that people feel like they don't have time [00:43:00] or they don't prioritize these kinds of things.
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I, I think, I think you need to have a very good chair that sets the rules for the good Board. And unfortunately, um, not all the boards and members in place at the moment are probably the most ideal people in place.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: But unless people from healthcare and health background like you and, and myself, and if we don't step back and get involved, we're gonna have lots and lots of commercially driven institutionalized people driving those agenda through. Mm. So, so I think, yes, they should change. Yes, we should hold them to, to higher ideals.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yes, there is guidelines set up by the AICD (Australian Institute of Company Directors). But at the same time, we just can't be a bystander.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: We have to put our hands up, stick our head out in the neck, get involved in leadership, learn the skills. And at the same time, I think we as senior members [00:44:00] support those people coming through. If we don't support the next generation coming through, then, then we're gonna have a generation that, that will always, like you said, "My identity as a doctor, as a psychologist, as a surgeon, as a physician is not my identity, it's helping to manage governance."
Sharee Johnson: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: And it should be recognized as a complete identity- Both sides of the equation, one person
Sharee Johnson: I want to underline something you said there about sponsorship and this idea of, um, helping the younger people or the newer people into leadership and governance. Actively helping them, not just having a-
Sharee Johnson: mentor relationship between the two of you, but saying to other people, "So and so has great skills. So and so is keen to learn. So and so would be good on this project." This active sponsoring of people when they're not in the room even.
Dr Alwin Tan: Correct. Uh, absolutely. I think the most important people are the people that talk about you, put your name on the list and, and defend you- Mm
Dr Alwin Tan: when you're not in the room, you know?
Sharee Johnson: [00:45:00] Defend you a really great addition, yes. , I guess these are sort of opposite questions. What do you think of, as the clinician, what are the transferable skills?
Sharee Johnson: What are the things that you've been able to bring from your surgical clinical life into boardrooms and governance and so on? You mentioned humanity earlier. What else have you brought that's transferable?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think one of the thing is to be able to, to have the emotional intelligence to, to think about how would the patient feel, how would the healthcare person feel, and how would different people feel if you walk in their shoes.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know, I think that ability would help us become better leaders. But at the same time, realizing that we need to talk to people, we need to listen to people. When I ran trauma and I ran big surgical team, I made it a rule that anyone could stop and say, "Alwin, stop. I think we're gonna make a mistake." And even if it's wrong, we go, "Okay, thanks for checking with us."[00:46:00]
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm. Rather than saying, "Please don't waste my time." And I think, I think having that sort of attitude to be able to bring it to governance, it's an important story.
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: The story of dedication, um, trying to be better than your last person that you are, that always carries with me. Um, and, and I think the, the, the thought of making a common good, you know, when I was in, in, in Melbourne Business School, I was the guy who said, "Why should he make 90 cents and I make five cents?
Dr Alwin Tan: And why can't we all make 30 cents together?" And that used to drive my, um, business finance professor mad that like, "Are you in the right course?" Because, because I believe that if everyone have something to win, then everyone would come on the journey with you. Um, if, if, if one person win and five persons suffer, the five person, the other five person will [00:47:00] drop off.
Dr Alwin Tan: They will either keep quiet, do less, contribute less, or move on to the next in place to work. And I think it is important to think about the quietest person in the room and says, "Hey John, you haven't said anything. You know, what's your idea? You got five minutes. I want five minutes out of you." A- and I think that's...
Dr Alwin Tan: That has taught me because a- a- as I run, uh, companies now and I run institution, I keep reminding my, my, my myself, "This is where you come from, and please do not forget who you are." And that's the, the thing that I tell myself every day when I walk in
Sharee Johnson: Mm. So my opposite question, Alwin, is-
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm ...
Sharee Johnson: I have often said doctors want a seat at the table, but they don't have the skills.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm.
Sharee Johnson: So that's my opposite question. So there are some transferable skills, and also there are some gaps. So you've been really attending to the, the gaps that you've seen. You've been at- Yep ... the director's [00:48:00] course, Melbourne Business School, Harvard, Oxford, you know, lots of things. What, what do you say about this idea that doctors want a seat at the table, but they don't have the skills?
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. I, I think just because you're a great clinician and you're a great team leader in, in, in operating theaters, in physician groups, in psychology, in meeting, does not make you a good manager, does not make you a governance person. And I think it's like anything, you know. You start as an intern.
Dr Alwin Tan: You understand that this is some language you don't know, and you accept that you're gonna learn it, and you can learn it various ways, right? You can read, you can go on the internet, you can do courses online. Um, I don't, I don't encourage everyone to, to take time off to do an MBA for two years, but, but, you know, the Melbourne Business School has now a nice ecosystem called the Bastas.
Dr Alwin Tan: Uh, Dennis Bastas, through DBJ, donated $76 million to [00:49:00] form this institution called, the Bastas Academy for Health Leadership. That allows people from all part of healthcare, even the lawyers come and join us, um, who talks about the healthcare system and learn about leadership skills. And these are small- You know, eligible courses including AI at, Melbourne Business School.
Dr Alwin Tan: And all doctors, healthcare workers listening to this should join in send me an email and I will give you the link.
Sharee Johnson: We, we will also put it in the show notes, Alwin, so
Dr Alwin Tan: Correct. Correct. And I think you're right. You, you go and look for information, you learn what to do, you find mentors.
Dr Alwin Tan: Be curious. Um, be able to learn and be able to say, "I don't know this, um, but I want to learn this." You know? That was my, my line every day when I walk into business school and going, "I have no idea what this lecture's all about, but I'm gonna learn about this today." [00:50:00] And I think that's, that's how my curiosity starts, and my curiosity now continues, you know?
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. I love that. I think that, there's some really important things that we teach in our programs, which is curiosity, presence, kindness of course. But, but this curiosity, it's so vital. It keeps us vital, actually.
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. , Let's move on a little bit. You have a startup, it's called My Vitals Vault.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm. And you've made it ready in our conversation your interest in AI. So let's, let's shift a little bit and think about, um, My Vitals Vault and AI. Okay. What would you like us to, to know- Okay ... about that? And, and tell us what it's like to be a founder, I, I guess.
Dr Alwin Tan: Okay. So first of all, being a founder is very hard, and it is full of struggles.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I am very grateful that I've got into two accelerator program. One is AUSCEP (Australian Clinical Entrepreneur Program), uh, which we graduated last year, and ANDHealth (Australian's National Digital Health Initiative), which is a big powerhouse, and we're going through that and hopefully graduate at [00:51:00] the end of this year. Now, our program, My Vitals Vault, came about quite easily. Um, it's my frustration.
Dr Alwin Tan: Every time a patient comes to me, they bring bundles and bundles of history with them, and you look through the history and you go, "Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah." And you go through the whole story. And one day they arrive, and you go, "Where is your history?" He said, "We've missed the file. Dad misplaced it. The dog ate it."
Dr Alwin Tan: And then true, everyone is trying to build, um, electronic, um, medical records, but they're all locked in every institution.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: So for example, today, if you had surgery at the Alfred, and tonight you go to Royal Melbourne casualty, they'll have no idea what you've been done because the Privacy Act locks it in.
Dr Alwin Tan: But what if you have an outside system, a system that allows the patient to carry his history across institution, across [00:52:00] countries, across emergencies, and at a time of need, where the patient is, it releases a code that tells you what you are. Example, Sharee, let's say that you are in Delhi and you collapsed, and you had peanut allergy that no one knows about.
Dr Alwin Tan: And this app, upon your collapse, would release saying, "I'm Sharee. This is the phone numbers to call for my doctors. And please, I've got peanut allergy." And it's written in Hindi or Malayalam if you're in Southern India. What you have... What if you have that program? That will allow us to cross across barrier, carrying our own information at a moment of need.
Dr Alwin Tan: But what happens if this is an in-an indigenous person, a refugee person who goes from one country to the next, or an indigenous person coming from, you know, from the country to a tertiary institution, they would carry the history with them. All the crux of the story [00:53:00]
Sharee Johnson: Mm. So what, what- you're describing is that I as the patient own my own file.
Sharee Johnson: It's not owned by the government, it's not owned by any particular hospital. It's m- it's mine, that I own. So it's a membership site at some, some level. I buy off you the, the, the, my folder, if you like.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely.
Sharee Johnson: There's a lot of little tiny detail practical things I dont want to deal with here- Yeah yeah. But I'm wondering- Yeah ... about the privacy particularly moving across countries. ... While it sounds very appealing, the, the international part of it sounds very appealing, that I can travel- Yeah ... the world with this all in my pocket, and if anything happens. Especially I think for the aging population who do a lot of traveling.
Dr Alwin Tan: Correct.
Sharee Johnson: Probably immediately interesting to them. How do you manage, what's involved in understanding the privacy from country to country? Yeah. Is that tricky?
Dr Alwin Tan: Right. Right. So, um, well, we're just gonna say what I can say within my NDA. It allows, the information is encrypted and carried by the patient.
Speaker 2: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: It's not owned by the platform. Mm. So, so a lot of, um, healthcare network carries [00:54:00] it on platform, because platform allows them to control the patient coming in and out. We don't do that. Mm. We allow the patient to carry it. Um, that's probably as much as I can say. Yeah. Without breaching the NDA.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. We're about, we're about to launch. Well, once we launch, Sharee- Yeah ... I will make you one of my first customers.
Sharee Johnson: So I understand this, there's emerging technology and, you know- Yeah ... there's always a lot of, uh, work gone on before it, it reaches, uh, us- Yeah ... as the u- end user.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah.
Sharee Johnson: That must be another big learning place for you in terms of the tech?
Dr Alwin Tan: Oh. I, so i- I was very lucky that when I was sitting in Melbourne Business School, I pitched the ideas to e- to eight of us. From different background. We got a nurse, we got an operations manager, we got a finance manager, we got two I- I- IT gurus. A- and that was how the whole thing started. It was from a couple of, uh, Melbourne Business School buddies having a few beers, and me pitching an ideas.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that's [00:55:00] how As you can see, probably our super energy force because our super source, because we have got people from different fields. And that has made learning a lot easier. But not, but still, it's a long way out. You know, it's a long way out before we scale, commercialize, and be big.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, all of us look at it as this is a learning curve. And if we do well, good on us. Mm. If, if we d- if, if we have to pivot and stop, it has been a great experience. Mm. And we value those experience with us to the next generation.
Sharee Johnson: I, I really love that you said that because l- again, a lot of the work I do with people is helping them not just be outcome focused.
Sharee Johnson: It's really important to be outcome focused. It's often important to start with the end in mind to work out where we're going, what we're doing. But we don't want to miss the experience, the process, the thing- Oh ... all the things that happen along the way, which you've just pointed to. I, I really love. Thank you for saying that.
Sharee Johnson: I love that. It,
Dr Alwin Tan: it, it's beautiful, . It's, it's a gorgeous day. [00:56:00]
Sharee Johnson: And you referred to the, entrepreneurial programs that have helped you with that part of the learning. Do you want to say something? Maybe there's a message for potential founders who are listening- Yeah, um-
Sharee Johnson: who are thinking they'd like to do something outside of their mainstream health work.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah, I, I think there are a lot of university drives and ecosystem out there that you'll never be aware of, you know? Uh, Melbourne Uni has a strong one. RMIT has a strong one. Deakin has a strong one. Monash has a strong one.
Dr Alwin Tan: So apply
Sharee Johnson: incubators is what I was thinking
Dr Alwin Tan: of. Yeah. Yeah, the incub- incubators. Yeah. And then Launch Victoria, which changed its name to Innovation Victoria now, um, has got lots and lots of, incubation system where you can join, turn up, and learn a new language. Mm. Meet new people, talk about change.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I find those experience really, really exciting, really, really lovely. And I'm probably running to the next meeting, you know. So for all of you who wants to do it, and if, if you can think of, think of ... Reach out to me, I'm happy to point you in the right direction. [00:57:00] And, um, there are lots of people out there to help you.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and there are lots of drive to see you succeed, you know. And there are lots of- ecosystem where you could join, and they're not gonna take any equity in your invention at all. All they want to do is to see you grow.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, uh, and, and that's a beautiful culture that we have in Victoria. Mm. And I thank Victoria, and I thank Innovation Victoria and all the universities who have put a lot of work into it.
Dr Alwin Tan: And no doubt I will be putting my hand up to, to come back and mentor people and help them along the way.
Sharee Johnson: It's lovely to think of, even, you know, looking at the joy on your face while you're talking about all of this, this expansive, this big field of vision that opens up in front of you.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah.
Sharee Johnson: It's just such a lovely contrast to the experience that, uh, doctors often have inside health that's contracting and, getting smaller and smaller. Like, "Well, I'll do less, and I won't go to those committees, and I'll-- out of frustration I'll just contract." And this experience of really expanding [00:58:00] and seeing a bigger, wider world and more opportunity.
Dr Alwin Tan: I know. I think, I think a lot of, uh, the healthcare frontline workers, doctors, nurses like to tell me there's more responsibility put on them- Mm ... and less power-
Sharee Johnson: Mm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: given to them. So, so while they're at the forefront do- taking all the responsibility and compliance issues, the power lies behind them. And, and I think these sort of things open the doors for us.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know, gives us a different window- Mm ... different, different looks in life, and a different venture and different, um, way of learning things.
Sharee Johnson: Shall we just talk about power for a second?
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm, mm.
Sharee Johnson: So, so y- you know, we've-- have touched on it a bit, but I'll just maybe just go back again to why it's important.
Sharee Johnson: You're looking at the patient, you're looking at forward and front and how to progress the patient's wellbeing and their health and so on, and now you're looking in behind and saying, "Well, what about the governance? How do I help in a bigger, systemic kind of way?" What's the shift you need to do mentally in [00:59:00] your mindset about the power differential?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think that comes from, um, two things. Um, maturity and also mentorship.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know? I- if, if, if we see somebody who is in healthcare who is good clinically, but also good in a governance role, then people start to think, you know? Everyone's watching. They're saying, "Hey, I could contribute there. I could do something about it."
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, because if you sit down with any healthcare worker and you have a cup of coffee, they will have a list of things that they think that they could change.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: But there, there's no way for them to give this pipeline to someone or even represent themselves. And to do that, you can either elect a representative that will help you, but often If you really feel the need to do it, and a lot of us do, then you need to equip yourself with the [01:00:00] capacity to get involved.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And only when you get involved can make changes in the ecosystem, and only when you're involved you can you do something. And sometimes, I agree, the ecosystem is so bad that you can't do it, then it's probably time to change. Jump to the next spot. Oh, yes. And move on.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. I think the, I think the most resilient people...
Sharee Johnson: Tait Shanafelt's work around leadership in, in health says that, 30% of doctors are at that most resilient end, and even they will burn out, in the right poor conditions. And, some work from Nick Petrie, he's a behavioral scientist in New Zealand- Mm ... says that, um, the thriving, thriving leaders, there's about 3% of them that really thrive and do well even whatever the circumstances.
Sharee Johnson: And, and some of what I interpret this is that the most resilient people will be on committees, will try really hard, will be head of department, will do all sorts of things to try and affect the system. But ultimately at some point they will leave. Ultimately they'll say- Mm ... "I can't [01:01:00] change this system. I've given everything I've got. I've tried really hard. I'm going somewhere else with my skills now." People are shocked when I say that, I think the most resilient people will leave because they can see doesn't matter how much adapting and learning I do here, what I have to offer can be used better somewhere else.
Dr Alwin Tan: Ab- absolutely. And I think this goes along with the story that, a bad system cannot rely on resilient of the staff to survive.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and, and resilient staff all the time realize that the system is so toxic and so bad that they shouldn't be there because they can thrive better and make more impact elsewhere.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and sometimes it takes that realization and the courage, you know, because people have work, people have mortgages, people have family pressures, and people have expectations to actually stand up and actually go. And, and I have been, you know, I've had multiple nurses who sat in my room and said, "I can't work in this system anymore."
Dr Alwin Tan: And I says, "Please give me your CV, [01:02:00] and I'll write you a recommendation to go elsewhere." And a lot of them has come back and, and, and, and some of them still sends me pictures of little heart in the morning with a cup of coffee saying that, "I can't believe that I stayed in that system for so long, and I, I gave them so much.
Dr Alwin Tan: And now, I need to go somewhere else," you know. And that reminds me of a little story. If I could share this story. Please we've got a couple of nurses who, uh, who have worked nine years, onwards reaching 10 years to get their long service leave, and some of them has had mishap in their life.
Dr Alwin Tan: So they're gonna go and approach the, the management and said, "I've given you so many years of my life. I've done night shift. I've done double shift. I've done so many things for you guys. Can I now drop back from permanent to part-time?" In so doing, they still keep their long service leave.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Now, there are some institution, no names mentioned, who take [01:03:00] this as an opportunity to deprive their long-term workers from their long service leave by saying, "No, you can't. You have to reapply. You have to resign from your other job and resign." My heart sank when I heard that this is happening across our industry, that asks so much of the frontline workers, and when it is your time for your entitlement under the Fair Work law, they would say, "I'm sorry, you've got to resign and reapply for the other job," making it, "I'm sorry, we take your long service leave."
Dr Alwin Tan: And those system you know, for those of you who are in there, they're so toxic, guys. It's time to go. It's time to go somewhere where you're appreciated, yeah, you're loved, where people likes the work you do because people in healthcare really want the patients to do well. Unfortunately, executive in [01:04:00] healthcare, not all of them want their healthcare workers to do well at the same time.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that's the biggest, you know, imbalance that we can see today.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. I want to believe that all the people are good people.
Dr Alwin Tan: Sharee, Sharee, Sharee. Sharee, Sharee.
Sharee Johnson: And so I want... My story is that these executives have got such competing needs that they are in an impossible situation. You know, that they're trying to manage finances or whatever.
Sharee Johnson: I don't know if that's true. I've never tried to really test that in any um, scientific method kind of way. That's just my own what I want to believe about people. But, but h- how does that happen? Why, why, how can that happen that the frontline workers meet that? Because I hear that story too very often in all its forms.
Sharee Johnson: How do you understand that happening?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think it's very hard when, when you're fighting against a headwind, a tide that's coming your way and you're alone. Um, um, I [01:05:00] think as a healthcare workers, the doctors, nurses, uh, we are not unionized. We're not meant to work with each other. We're not meant to stand together in arms.
Dr Alwin Tan: We're meant to, to, uh, just strive on our own and quietly disappear, suffer alone, and, and people don't rally against each other, you know? Uh, if you have the building industry, someone got, got, got, got done by, the whole building industry would run to a halt. The whole railway industry would stop tomorrow and there'd be no trains, you know?
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, we don't have that. Un- until we have that together spirit, it's going to be a lot harder, guys. You know, if we don't stand together, the doctors have been working so many long hours for years. For the first time, I saw some doctors protesting this year. Uh, cultural change.
Dr Alwin Tan: But if you're talking to any other industry, we go, "Yeah, we do that all the time. Where have you guys been?" And I think there must be a mind shift. [01:06:00] Unless we teach leadership- In medical school and as people grow up through the health ecosystem in nursing and psychology, we're not gonna have a generation of people that can step in and said, "This is wrong. We need to stand up, put this together." And I think that greater good has to come.
Sharee Johnson: Mm. I have two reactions, Alwin and one is I worry that, um, some of the thinking around AI is that we're losing... we lose our capacity for discernment and judgment, and that that's very critical for our-
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm ...
Sharee Johnson: um, younger doctors and other professions that our senior doctors, doctors like you, have had to use your own judgment a lot before AI. And so you can look at the AI and discern that, "Oh, that's not quite right," or, "There's something funny there." And there's some concern that younger doctors who are using AI earlier won't be able to pick that up when they're looking at the AI.
Sharee Johnson: So I'm, I was thinking about that as you're talking. Oh. And then I think- I think I- And then I'm [01:07:00] also thinking about the, the protesters, the, uh, allied health people are protesting as well in Victoria this year, and of course the psychiatrists had their issues in New South Wales last year. You know, this collective action, there is a change in the air and we have real examples now of, you know, the junior doctors in New South Wales and Victoria getting their back pay for overtime we have real examples now of-
Dr Alwin Tan: Mm ...
Sharee Johnson: of collective action, and why it's needed. So I'm just trying to hold all of these things as you're-
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, but that's, that's two topics to talk about.
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. But AI i- is my very big, big topic to talk about. Mm. Um, it- it's been, been my big story. I think AI is gonna change a lot of things today. First of all, from a patient point of view, I've got patient coming in now that I've never seen before, that has put their referral into AI. And they will come in and said, "I've got this lesion somewhere, and I think it's cancer. And I wanna talk about the type of surgery you're gonna do on me." And, and, and often you have [01:08:00] to unpack them these days by saying, "What research have you done? Can you share your research with me first?" A question that I never used to ask, and now that's almost a starting point.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: A- And we're also finding that that's quite hard because even if we acknowledge that- A, a fraction or a number of patients, especially the younger generation, they believe the AI more than we- they, they believe us.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And so if our opinion contradict them, they say, "I don't believe you because AI says this, I'm not coming back." So we're seeing that sort of group of patients. So, so that's gonna be a big challenge for the next generation of doctors dealing with the next generation of AI obsessed driven, uh, culture, which is going through almost every patient.
Dr Alwin Tan: I think that's a big topic to talk about. The second thing about AI and thinking, I think was, was quite important. So when I was going through, um, Melbourne Business School, I only graduated end of last year, the policy was you can't use AI. [01:09:00] So then at, at one of the discussion, I, I sat down with the professors and says, "Hey guys, even though you put that rules in, I can tell you that everyone in the cohort is using AI, and what are you doing to change the policy?"
Dr Alwin Tan: So this year, the policy have changed. All of a sudden University of Melbourne and Business School is saying, "Well, you can use AI, but you have to show h- how you use it," or, or for those exams where we are not going to let you use AI, it's gonna be an oral exams where you have to turn up in person and drop all your device or a handwritten exams with no computers and only basic calculators allowed.
Dr Alwin Tan: So I think institution needs to grow up. Everyone's gonna use it, and if we're going to, going to assess people in the mental side, we have to either allow it or not allow it. But if you're not gonna allow it, then set it up nicely so it's fair and square. Now, the, the third question about [01:10:00] medicine, this is an interesting story.
Dr Alwin Tan: I was taking a couple of medical students around and, you know, usually you stand around there and you go, "Okay, he has chest pain. So what are the differential diagnosis?" And while someone is answering, the other two people are checking the ChatGPT for, for differential diagnosis. And that was very, very concerning.
Dr Alwin Tan: They say, "Oh, we do that all the time. We, we, we check it." So these days when I run my tute, I, I bring in a little, little box, metal tin, and says, "Please drop your phone all in." We close it, leave it at the front desk, and then the tute actually start. So unless you actually do that, people are going to start have attrition of their mind.
Dr Alwin Tan: And you're very right, you know. In, in psychology, you guys, your, your superhero skill is, is your mind and your thinking skill. And if you're gonna rely on AI, it's going to be a different world and, and a challenging world. And I think we risk, transferring our thinking responsibility to a device that may not be the [01:11:00] best for our patients.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm. Well, I think that those things are coming up because you mentioned about teaching leadership in med school, and the curriculum is already huge. ... I think it's not just about adding things, it's about taking things off as well, isn't it? Because we do have these different tools.
Dr Alwin Tan: Correct. I think it's a different time and, the people that come through must be more rounded, robust, be able to look after the patient in front, but also be able to deal with the institution behind them.
Sharee Johnson: Yeah. So any, any thoughts, Alwin, on making decisions under pressure? What's your, what's your-
Sharee Johnson: either for governance and leadership or for cl- clinical
Sharee Johnson: leadership?
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. I, I think, I think back in when, when surgery, trauma, transplant was my bread and butter, it's about decision on the spot.
Sharee Johnson: Mm-hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And at the same time, all those decision that comes through, you carry it.
Dr Alwin Tan: Whatever happens, you're captain of the ship. You don't, you don't offload [01:12:00] to someone else. , I remembered when we had trauma cases or when a patient has a bad outcome, I used to invite the families in, into a room, a hall, and I put my chair in the middle and I sit down, and it's a very painful day.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I would say, "Please tell me what you think." And some of the comments would be very hard, very painful, very personal. Some would be very abusive. But if you, if you can hold it up for 30 minutes and not get angry and speak back, then you say, "Okay, I take all that back. Take all you said, but now can I tell you our, our story?"
Dr Alwin Tan: And then be, be transparent and be able to say sorry, we, we get it wrong. And that set of cultures is the cultures that I still carry today, even as a leader in governance. Unfortunately, the people that I sit around in the board who are not doctors, they don't, they don't do this. Mm. A lot of institution has this thing, "All right, we made a mistake, so now how can we defend ourself?
Dr Alwin Tan: What are the risks? [01:13:00] Let's speak to our lawyers. What can we say to minimize the damage to us?" And, and that's a totally different shift, and I'm really sad to see institution who knowingly that they have made mistake refuse to admit it, refuse to roll it back, and refuse to acknowledge the impact that the people that have cost.
Dr Alwin Tan: And that sometimes put me at, headlocks, but I'm one... not one of those people that will keep quiet given where I am today, Sharee. And I say, "Excuse me, guys. I'm gonna say something uncomfortable. This is wrong. You guys can't, can't get away with it because we know it's wrong.
Dr Alwin Tan: We cannot pretend that it's not there." And a lot of time institution tries to bury it under paperwork, bury it un- under lots of procedures. And one of my biggest, um... every time I hear this it really makes my soul burn when they say, "We follow procedures. We are, we are governance proof."
Sharee Johnson: Mm. "
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and we follow the process. We've done this right." A- and sometimes you're [01:14:00] gonna say, "Guys, the process is so bad, um, and so wrong. Can we not change this?" You know? And I think that that's one of the things about making decision. The other thing about making decision these days is about step back, take time.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: Um, listen to everyone else. Think about the pros and cons. Don't make the decision today. sleep on it tonight. I, I, I believe in that, that I, mentally when I'm asleep I actually start thinking about the problem. And next day I thought, "All right, I'm a bit calmer now. I'm less emotional. How would I approach this?"
Dr Alwin Tan: And I've learned that. I've learned that as a part of growing emotional intelligence, and I think it take years. You know, when you get a few gray hair like me, it, it starts to come.
Sharee Johnson: Can't see any gray hairs coming from a person with a lot of gray hair. It,
Dr Alwin Tan: it's fas- fa- it's fashionable, Sharee.
Dr Alwin Tan: It's fashionable to have silver hair.
Sharee Johnson: So, so, um, it, it's tempting to think that, [01:15:00] there's a luxury that you have now as a senior person in being able to speak your mind a bit more. I wanna point for our younger listeners to say that we've talked about collective action a lot, we've talked about sponsorship, and we've talked about the relationship that you described with Peter.
Sharee Johnson: There are ways from wherever you are in the hierarchy that you can get to be active in these processes. And, uh, yes, it's very real that if you stick your head up a- above the parapet that there are risks. So we wanna think about which, which things we wanna fight and what the timing is and who can be our advisors, and those kinds of things.
Sharee Johnson: I think you are providing a little bit of, um, you know, real-life encouragement for people to think about how and when and where they can speak. And I want to encourage the people listening to start running small experiments. Start testing, putting your toe in the water. And also I want to recognize that you didn't just start you're not just sort of talking blind. You're also [01:16:00] investing a lot in your own education around tech, around leadership, around business. So I, I just feel like it's good to- none of this has happened by accident
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. I think, I think one of the most humbling thing is as you learn more, um, this is sound a bit, bit philosophical, that you actually learn that there's so much more to learn.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and my thirst for knowledge and to grow since Melbourne Business School has grown so much, you know? I, and I no longer see myself just as a surgeon, that's my identity. I see myself as a leader. I see myself as a forefront governance. I see myself as a person that stand up for the little people, you know?
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and my, my father would laugh today because he wanted me to, to, to be one of those, uh, human right people and fight for the little people. And now, years after he is gone, I, I have turned the full circle and say, " it's my turn. It's my turn to provide the voice and the platform."
Sharee Johnson: Well, I, I, I hope he's feeling very proud of you.
Sharee Johnson: Can we talk, speaking of fathers, [01:17:00] can we talk about your very special relationship, um, with a Wurundjeri man who has essentially adopted you as, as his son? Can you tell us that story?
Dr Alwin Tan: I think that's one of the most honorable thing that I will carry with me for the rest of my life.
Speaker 2: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: You know? Um, I, I looked after Murrundindi as, as a patient, as a friend, as a father for over 15 years.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: And we got along, and he teaches me about the culture, the people. Uh, he even, he even taught me how to use the didgeridoo badly. So, so, so, so some days when I'm brave enough, I turn up to Healesville Sanctuary wearing a cap and sunglasses and hide. But on his 80th birthday last year, um, he came to my room and said, "Alwin, I'm gonna make you son.
Dr Alwin Tan: I'm gonna adopt you into the mob." And I, I was shocked. I didn't think that was possible, and I didn't think that was such an honor to be carried. And, [01:18:00] um, and so we, we went to his, uh, birthplace, which is in Coranderrk, which is Healesville Sanctuary. And there, where, he was born and his mother grew up, , I was, I was, I was made Mamook, um, which means, uh, a, a, a wild spirit, and son of Murrundindi the first Asian boy in 40,000 years history to be adopted.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I am so honored to carry this honor. And, and it makes my responsibility to, to try and, and think about inclusivity and, and, and, and also to see what I can champion from a health point of view to the Indigenous, the Indigenous people, um, you know, that, that comes through. And, um, understand the history, um, in this country that has been controversial and had, uh, had at some stage has not been spoken. And it's so nice to see that now these days that it is okay to speak about, it [01:19:00] is okay to bring it out. And I'm very happy to walk this journey and to learn this from my great-
Speaker 2: Mm ...
Dr Alwin Tan: um, dad, and also part of the Wurundjeri people.
Sharee Johnson: It, it feels like full circle to talk about, um, technology and AI and all the things that happen in medicine, and then to come all the way back around to the, the original people of this land and, and our connection and, and, um, you know, maybe some hope around inclusivity and diversity that we perhaps have been losing a bit with some of the right-wing politics that's happening around the world.
Sharee Johnson: Do you feel encouraged at all?
Dr Alwin Tan: Yeah. Yeah. In the geopolitical things, the last few years ha- has been, has been controversial and harder to see. Um, but I think that, uh, I think the Australia of today, and I like to think the Australia of tomorrow, will be a bit more inclusive, more aware and to acknowledge this historical history of the people that walked [01:20:00] this land 40,000 years before us as migrants coming into this place.
Dr Alwin Tan: And, and, and to incorporate that as part of the culture, the life, and where things would be. And I think also to understand that there's so much wisdom that we're not learning from, and, and this is only the tip of the iceberg. And, and it's a beautiful time. It's a beautiful time to see this change, especially, you know, with the parliament, um, in Victoria ma- um, change, changing the act to follow.
Dr Alwin Tan: I'm a great supporter of inclusivity and diversity, not just for the way we say it is. You know, when we say inclusivity, we, we don't expect someone different to fit into what we have in a community, but, but more in terms of how that person brings into our community and change it of, of today.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I think to, to change that mindset would take time, but at the same time, it, it's a job and a responsibility for all of us as current Australians and future Australians of tomorrow. [01:21:00]
Sharee Johnson: Mm. Well, it requires some intention and some consciousness, doesn't it? So it's- It
Dr Alwin Tan: does ...
Sharee Johnson: um- We've covered so much ground, Alwin.
Sharee Johnson: Is there anything at all, do you want to pick up? Is there anything we need to go back and just tidy up in any shape or form?
Dr Alwin Tan: No. Okay. I think it is beautiful. It, it's such a good time, a stopgap to reflect. I think it is, it is beautiful, and I'm honored that, Sharee, that you picked me for, for this conversation.
Dr Alwin Tan: And I'm honored to share and, and whatever I can do to help out, to pitch out. And anybody who needs some advice, help, reach out. I'm, I'm, I'm out there.
Sharee Johnson: Have you got a mantra for this part of your life, this, this changing, all the different learning that you're doing? What's the mantra that you tell yourself to keep going when you're feeling a bit weary with all these big, complex things?
Dr Alwin Tan: I, I think it goes back to the guy who built, Machu Picchu. You know, he, he wrote that on the wall. It says that, "Learn every day as if you're gonna live 100 years."
Dr Alwin Tan: Live every day [01:22:00] as if you're gonna die tomorrow."
Sharee Johnson: Hmm.
Dr Alwin Tan: One of my greatest teachers told me this,
Dr Alwin Tan: at the end of life, it's about love, it's about memories, and it's about dust. Every second that we've got, every time we've got, should be doing something that makes you happy or make the world a better place.
Sharee Johnson: Mm.
Dr Alwin Tan: My job is both.
Sharee Johnson: Mm. Beautiful. Beautiful. Thank you so much, Alwin. I really look forward- Thank
Dr Alwin Tan: you
Speaker 2: to whenever we might meet again, and I hope that's not too far away.
Dr Alwin Tan: Thank you so much, Sharee. Thank you.
[01:23:00]